HomePizzaPeppe’s Pizza - Plains - NEPA Pizza Overview

Peppe’s Pizza – Plains – NEPA Pizza Overview


Peppe’s Pizza in Plains is a superb little hidden gem within the Wilkes-Barre space. Many individuals “within the know” have really useful I do this pizzeria over time. Fortunately, I discovered myself within the space and known as in an order for a medium pizza with candy sauce. I’m usually an everyday sauce man, however the suggestions was overwhelmingly in favor of the candy sauce – so I went with what the folks really useful.

When driving as much as Peppe’s Pizza, I undoubtedly felt a familiarity with the realm, and as soon as I noticed Plains Pub throughout the road I knew why! Pepe’s is an old style pizzeria the place you’ll be able to see proper into the kitchen. It’s as all the way down to earth as you may get.

Blast From the Previous!

Shaggy dog story, I finished in for the primary time and the proprietor was extraordinarily welcoming to me and we acquired to speaking. As we talked, I undoubtedly knew that we had met earlier than – after which it hit me! We had labored collectively at a pizzeria for a short while a pair a long time in the past! We shared some reminiscences, I snapped a number of images of the pizza and I excused myself to go evaluation the pizza in personal (aka on the hood of my automotive)!

Pepe’s Pizza Plains beautifully cooked bottom crust.
A have a look at the superbly baked backside crust of Pepe’s Pizza in Plains.

The pizza seemed excellent. It was a skinny crust New York fashion pizza cooked good and crispy, barely on the nicely performed facet identical to I prefer it! The cheese was melted superbly and caramelized in some spots. It had a richness and slight saltiness to it that contrasted the sweeter sauce magnificently. The sauce had a beautiful physique and clean texture to it. The sweetness was introduced in a novel approach that wasn’t overpowering or sugary, and had a satisfying mellow tang to it.

General, I used to be very impressed with the pizza. It’s a no frills throwback pizzeria stuffed with character and character. Folks advised me it was a welcoming place and the proprietor made me really feel like an everyday the second I stepped within the door. Extremely suggest!

Peppe’s Pizza Score Scores

Pepe’s Pizza Plains New York Style Pizza with Sweet Sauce
Pepe’s Pizza Plains New York Model Pizza with Candy Sauce
  • Restaurant: Peppe’s Pizza & Subs
  • Location: 52 E Carey St, Wilkes-Barre, PA 18705
  • Date: April 2023
  • Pizza Ordered: Medium New York Model with Candy Sauce
Score Class Score Rating
Crust 8.5
Sauce 8.3
Cheese 8.3
Style 8.6
Crispy/Cooked Correctly 9.1
Worth 7.6
General Score 8.5
Score of Peppe’s Pizza in Plains Candy Sauce Pizza

The Pizza is Just like: Shelley’s Pizza, Dino and Francesco’s, Grande Pizza




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments