HomeCocktailStrawberry Jello Pie - The Cookie Rookie®

Strawberry Jello Pie – The Cookie Rookie®


Becky Hardin


This submit could embody affiliate hyperlinks that earn us a small fee out of your purchases at no additional price to you.

This strawberry jello pie is bound to fulfill your candy tooth. Made with contemporary strawberries, this easy fruit pie takes minutes to make and is bursting with taste.

fork with bite out of slice of strawberry jello pie with whipped cream

What’s on this Recipe for Jello Strawberry Pie?

With simply 5 elements (water and whipped cream don’t depend!) and 10 minutes of prep, this strawberry jello pie would possibly simply be the best show-stopper dessert ever!

  • Water: You’ll want water to hydrate the Jell-O and create a suspension for the strawberries.
  • Sugar: Granulated sugar helps to sweeten this pie. Begin with somewhat and style as you go. When you’ve got tart strawberries, I’d recommend including the complete quantity. For sweeter strawberries, add much less.
  • Cornstarch: Strawberries are filled with water, so including some cornstarch helps take up a few of that free water, thickening this pie and stopping the filling from turning into too runny.
  • Strawberry Jell-O: The flavour base for this pie that offers it its signature jiggly texture.
  • Pie Crust: Retailer-bought pre-made pie crust is ok, or make your individual pie crust!
  • Strawberries: Contemporary strawberries add contemporary fruity taste and texture to this pie.

Professional Tip: Use contemporary quite than frozen strawberries for this recipe. Frozen fruits are both prone to keep frozen, or, launch an excessive amount of liquid into the jello.

Variations on Strawberry Pie with Jello

This pie is fairly scrumptious as it’s, however it’s simple to make use of this base recipe to make any fruit jello pie you want. You possibly can simply adapt this to make use of totally different fruits and flavored Jell-O. Raspberry and orange are each nice selections. You too can swap out the pie crust for a graham cracker crust in the event you’re feeling fancy!

step by step photos for how to make strawberry jello pie

Trademark Word: Within the spirit of transparency, I need to be aware that a few of these elements are trademarked merchandise. Jell-O is a proprietary model that I need to acknowledge and provides credit score to.

Can I make strawberry jello pie with frozen strawberries?

Technically, sure, however it actually gained’t be the identical. Contemporary berries have a firmer form and are rather more satisfying to chew into than thawed berries. Moreover, the beforehand frozen berries could or could not maintain their form within the jello pie. Nonetheless, in the event you’re unable to search out any contemporary berries, you may try to make use of frozen ones by permitting them to thaw first at room temperature for a number of hours. Then, comply with the directions accordingly.

Can I make this pie with sugar free jello?

You positive can! You’ll want about 0.4 ounces of sugar-free jello, which is a little more than 1 field, so purchase 2 simply to be secure! You too can use a sugar-free baking sweetener (like Swerve) rather than the granulated sugar!

How lengthy does it take jello to set?

You’ll want not less than 2-4 hours to let the gelatin absolutely set within the fridge. I like to recommend chilling it in a single day for finest outcomes.

Why is my jello pie runny?

Making jello can really feel like a science experiment! For those who add an excessive amount of or too little of an ingredient, it may throw the entire thing out of whack. If the jello remains to be skinny and runny after cooling for 15-20 minutes, you might need added a bit an excessive amount of water. Every time I make this recipe, I at all times purchase an additional jello field or 2 simply in case this occurs. In case your combination is just too skinny, begin over with a brand new field and add much less water.

How lengthy will strawberry jello pie keep contemporary?

Ensure to cowl the pie dish with plastic wrap or aluminum foil so it stays contemporary! Some other pie container with an hermetic lid must also do the trick. As soon as it’s in an hermetic container or wrap, place the pie within the fridge, the place it should keep contemporary for as much as 4 days.

Are you able to freeze jello pie?

Freezing and thawing gelatin will basically damage the feel, so it’s not beneficial that you simply freeze this jello pie.

overhead pic of sliced strawberry jello pie

Make Forward and Retailer Contemporary Strawberry Pie with Jello

It is a nice make-ahead dessert, excellent in case you are planning to serve it as a part of a giant feast. As soon as the jello has set, cowl the pie with plastic wrap and it’ll maintain effectively for 4 days.

It’s finest to not freeze it, as the feel of the jello can change fairly significantly as soon as it’s thawed.

What to Serve with Jello Strawberry Pie

This strawberry jello pie, in my humble opinion, needs to be served with some contemporary whipped cream. Vanilla ice cream additionally makes a pleasant topping. It’s additionally by no means a nasty thought so as to add somewhat grated chocolate to the highest, in the event you like. For those who’re feeling adventurous, attempt topping yours with a drizzle of balsamic glaze or lemon sauce!

up close slice of strawberry jello pie with whipped cream

Extra Strawberry Pie Recipes we Love




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments